Decision from the Round Table
- July 2015
Using a Cherokee Story in a
Feast of Tabernacles Lecture on the 33 Virtues
For the 2015
Feast of Tabernacles,
the
Divine Sisters are preparing a lecture on the 33
Virtues. To explain/exhibit the 22nd Virtue,
"Freedom from envy," one of the Sisters
suggested using
this Cherokee story. Another Sister,
however, questioned the use of non-Mission
teachings in the context of a lecture for the Feast
of Tabernacles explaining a Mission
idea (the 33 Virtues), even though the Cherokee
story is beautiful, has Truth, and is found on our
website (although not as part of the teachings, but
in the supplemental
By Disciples section).
The Sisters
submitted the question to the Round Table, which
resulted in the following written decision:
The Round Table has discussed the question of
using the Cherokee story, found in our "By
Disciples" section on the website, in the Divine
Sisters lecture. Our conclusion is that it
would not be ideal to do this, and we recommend
using only 100% Mission
materials in this situation (although the
Cherokee story is on our website, it is not by
Maitreya, but rather in the
section that presents information by others).
Our reasoning is as follows:
Overall, the goal is to find the "sweet spot"
where we use only 100% Mission
materials as much as possible without that
becoming rigid or dogmatic, stifling creativity
or expansion of the mind to other useful ideas
that fall under the Mission's
umbrella, etc. Each situation is
different. Here, we felt the following
considerations were important:
Each Virtue in the Divine Sisters
lecture only has a few minutes of time
dedicated to it. Considering this very
short time period, it is best to stay with
100% Mission materials
(which should be readily available to cover
such a short time). If there was a 2
hour lecture on the same topic (each
individual Virtue in this case), branching
out to some non-Mission
materials as part of it would be fine and
probably necessary.
-
The lecture will be
presented at an official Mission event (the
Feast of Tabernacles). Considering this, it
is best to keep it as Mission-oriented and
focused as possible.
-
The lecture is on an official Mission
topic. The 33 Virtues is a new, unique
Mission idea, first presented in
THOTH.
Considering this, we expect it is best
explained by Mission materials themselves,
and there should be ample material about it
on the website, etc. The situation would be
different if the topic was something more
general, for example genetics or farming,
where there is Mission material about it but
it is not a uniquely Mission idea and
bringing in other information would probably be very
useful, even in a short presentation.
-
Even considering the above, a non-Mission
material could be considered the best option
if it truly does something unique or
exceptional - makes the point in a way
nothing else could, or has special
significance considering the circumstances,
etc. Considering how short this presentation
of the Virtue will be, this sort of
"exception" would be very, very rare, and we
do not see such an exception here. Although
the Cherokee story is beautiful, there is
Mission material that can make the same
point just as well, and we see no other
reason why Mission-only material should not
be used here.
The reason we are going so in-depth and
detail in this recommendation is to hopefully
begin providing some guidelines or principles
others can use to help them make these decisions
in the future. This issue (where the "sweet
spot" is in terms of using Mission and
non-Mission information) will come up again and
again. Each situation is different, and these
are not the only important considerations, but
these are some of them. In general, a useful
question to ask is: Why am I using a non-Mission
idea/topic/quote/etc. here? Is it for a good
reason (from knowledge) that helps spread the
Mission and get the Mission done? Or is it for
another reason (from passion or ignorance) that
is not ideal? This serves as a good starting
point in deciding how to approach these kinds of
situations.
The Round Table (RT) of the Mission of
Maitreya
Note: If you do not understand
the reasoning behind the decision above, or
would like more clarification, etc., you can
contact the Round Table about it at:
RT@maitreya.org.
|